In a digital age where even the holiest leave behind online footprints, newly elected Pope Leo XIV, formerly Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, is drawing both praise and criticism for his past activity on social media.
Within minutes of his election as the first American Pope, online sleuths had already begun dissecting Prevost’s posts on X (formerly Twitter), revealing a mix of faith-driven reflections and pointed commentary on U.S. political figures, including Donald Trump and Vice President J.D. Vance.
Prevost, who hails from Chicago, had previously shared posts criticizing Trump’s immigration policies and Vance’s views on Christian duty toward immigrants.
One post from mid-April saw him amplify a Catholic commentator’s rebuke of Trump and El Salvador’s president over a deportation case, asking, “Is your conscience not disturbed?”
Some conservatives expressed alarm at Prevost’s apparent stances on immigration, gun control, and racial justice. Far-right commentator Laura Loomer called him a “Marxist puppet,” while Turning Point USA’s Charlie Kirk offered a cautious welcome, urging the new pope to prioritize “strong borders and sovereignty.”
Still, leaders across the political spectrum extended congratulations. Trump called it a “Great Honor” for America, while President Biden and former President George W. Bush hailed the moment as historic.
Despite the controversy, Pope Leo XIV’s online activity remains largely in line with mainstream Catholic values—underscoring his commitment to social justice, peace, and dignity for all.
