By Andrew Kariuki

Robert Alai has criticised the Orange Democratic Movement (ODM) over what he describes as internal inconsistencies, even as the party recently demanded “respect” from its coalition partner, UDA.

In a statement posted on his official X page, Alai questioned the party’s position, arguing that it must first address its own internal governance issues before calling out others.

At the centre of his criticism is the leadership of the ODM Youth League, where he claims the current office holder does not meet the constitutional definition of a youth.

“Right now… a 41-year-old man is occupying the position of ODM National Youth League Leader,” Alai said, referencing John Antira Ketora.

He cited Article 260 of the Constitution, which defines youth as persons aged between 18 and 35 years, arguing that the continued occupancy of the position raises questions about compliance with both constitutional and party standards.

Alai further questioned the party’s commitment to its own principles, particularly in light of its pledge to conduct “free and fair nominations” with “no sacred cows.”

“How can you talk about ‘no sacred cows’ when Ketora has been a sacred cow for six years?” he posed.

He also criticised the party’s planned youth conventions, questioning the legitimacy of such initiatives under the current leadership structure.

“Who will lead these conventions? A 41-year-old masquerading as a youth?” he asked.

The MCA also claimed that he had formally raised the issue with the party leadership in November 2025, calling for the position to be declared vacant and fresh elections conducted, but said he received no response.

“Five months of nothing,” he stated.

Alai went on to question ODM’s disciplinary processes, referencing ongoing concerns involving Nairobi Senator Edwin Sifuna, and arguing that the party cannot enforce discipline selectively.

“How can ODM talk about discipline when it has tolerated a constitutional violation for over six years?” he said.

While acknowledging that coalition partners should respect each other, Alai maintained that internal accountability is critical.

“Before you demand respect from coalition partners, respect your own Constitution,” he said.

ODM is yet to respond to the claims.