BBC -Talks between Russia, Ukraine and the US aimed at ending Moscow’s war in Ukraine have concluded without a breakthrough.
The trilateral meetings, held in Geneva, went on late on Tuesday but only lasted two hours on Wednesday.
Although US envoy Steve Witkoff had expressed optimism over the talks, both the chief Russian negotiator and Ukraine’s Volodymyr Zelensky indicated they had been “difficult”.
After the main talks concluded, Kremlin negotiator Vladimir Medinsky returned to the venue and held a closed-door meeting with the Ukrainian side for about an hour and a half. No details from that meeting have emerged.
Some progress was made on “military issues”, including the location of the front line and ceasefire monitoring, according to a Ukrainian diplomatic source.
But an agreement on the issue of territory – without which no ceasefire can be envisaged – remains elusive, with Moscow and Kyiv’s positions still far apart.
Russia has not budged in its demand for full control of the eastern Donbas region – made up of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions – which is a non-starter for Ukraine.
While conceding talks were challenging, Kremlin negotiator Vladimir Medinsky added that they had been “businesslike” and said another meeting would take place “soon”.
Zelensky also described the negotiations as “not easy” due to the difference in the two sides’ positions.
Rustem Umerov cut a less downbeat tone, saying the discussions had been “substantive and intensive” and that while there had been progress, no details could be disclosed “at this stage”.
“This is complex work that requires alignment among all parties and sufficient time,” Umerov said.
Shortly before the end of the talks was announced, Zelensky accused Russia of “trying to drag out negotiations that could already have reached the final stage”.
The Russian and Ukrainian delegations last metin US-brokered talks in Abu Dhabi earlier in February, which led to the first prisoner exchange in several months. On Wednesday, Zelensky indicated that another swap might be forthcoming.
US President Donald Trump, who spearheaded diplomatic efforts to end the war, has been signalling impatience with the deadlock between the two sides.
On Monday, he said Ukraine had “better come to the table, fast” – a sentiment Zelensky has since rejected, saying it was “not fair” that his country should be the one asked to compromise.
Four years on from the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, substantial distance still exists between Moscow’s demands and what Kyiv might consider a “just peace”.
Kyiv has long rejected Russia’s demand for the eastern Donbas, which would mean relinquishing Ukrainian sovereign territory, including several heavily fortified cities and a long defensive line in the region of Donetsk.
Many Ukrainians believe giving that territory up would leave the country vulnerable to another Russian invasion. Zelensky himself has drawn parallels with the 1938 Munich Agreement, when European powers let Hitler annex the Czech territory of Sudetenland.
On Tuesday, Zelensky told US media outlet Axios that any plan to hand over the Donbas would be rejected by Ukrainians if it were put to a referendum.
The Ukrainian president is also working to ensure that robust security guarantees to deter Russia from attacking again are provided by Kyiv’s western allies.
Another sticking point in the talks is the status of the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant.
The power plant – Europe’s largest – sits on the front line and has been under Russian control since March 2022. Ukraine wants Moscow to return it and Zelensky has previously said Kyiv could share control of the plant with the Americans – an arrangement Moscow is unlikely to agree to.
Officials from Britain, France, Germany and Italy were present in Geneva and held talks with the Ukrainians on the sidelines of the trilateral meeting.
European representatives have struggled to be included in the US-led negotiations, but Zelensky said European participation was “indespensable” for any final agreement.
Next Tuesday will mark the fourth anniversary of Moscow’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
The war, which has resulted in tens of thousands of military and civilian casualties and displaced millions across Ukraine, continues to shape the lives of Ukrainians, with daily deadly aerial attacks across the country.
Four people were killed and 30 injured in Russian artillery and air strikes overnight on Tuesday. Power infrastructure too continues to be targeted across the country, leaving millions without light or heating in one of Ukraine’s coldest winters in years.
